Skip to main content

Stock Market: The pros and cons of the MSCI upgrade

Eurokinissi

Most market participants acknowledge that entry into the Developed Markets category constitutes a positive development, enabling Greek listed companies to gain access to a vast pool of capital exceeding 18 trillion dollars

Προσθέστε την «Ν» ως προτιμώμενη πηγή στο Google

The market has interpreted MSCI’s decision to upgrade the Greek stock exchange to the “elite” of Developed Markets with strong enthusiasm—also supported by positive developments in the Middle East—albeit with certain reservations. This is despite the fact that the reclassification will take effect in May 2027 rather than in August 2026, as initially expected.

The decision to implement the reclassification over a 13–14 month horizon from the recent announcement raised questions regarding Athens’ current readiness to compete with Developed Markets. On the other hand, however, the short delay does not appear to alter the broader significance of the upgrade, namely that Athens is finally moving to a higher tier, closing a long cycle of inward-looking dynamics that began with the unprecedented downgrade in 2013.

It is worth noting that MSCI’s decision comes on top of FTSE Russell’s already announced move to classify Athens as a Developed Market as of September. Meanwhile, the corresponding verdict by Stoxx is expected in April, as the exchange has been on the provider’s watch list since last year for a potential review. Taking into account the latest developments, analysts agree that everything points to a clear trend regarding both the classification and the trajectory of the Athens market.

The pros of the upgrade

Most market participants acknowledge that entry into the Developed Markets category constitutes a positive development, enabling Greek listed companies to gain access to a vast pool of capital exceeding 18 trillion dollars. International experience supports this view, suggesting that integration in Developed Markets tends to yield favorable outcomes over the long term.

Thus, despite reservations among parts of the investment community, a broad consensus is emerging that, over time, the overall balance of the upgrade will be in favor of the more optimistic outlook.

That said, the forthcoming reclassification does not automatically create the conditions for an immediate surge in capital inflows. This is a point emphasized by the vast majority of international institutions. Notably, Morgan Stanley observes that capital outflows typically precede inflows, acting as a mechanism for short-term pressure. This largely reflects the forced exit of passive funds that invest exclusively in Emerging Markets equities.

In this context, the market interprets MSCI’s decision to postpone the upgrade by nine months—moving it to May 2027 from August 2026—as an attempt to mitigate this risk, providing a longer transition period for emerging market funds to complete their exit process with minimal disruption.

In any case, the expected increase in foreign institutional investor participation as a result of the upgrade is likely, among other things, to enhance market liquidity, improve overall market functioning, and support higher valuations for listed companies. At the same time, the benefits extend to the psychological level, as the move both ends the isolation of the Athens market—which until recently was the only Eurozone market classified as Emerging—and represents yet another vote of confidence in the country’s broader economic momentum.

The cons of the upgrade

On the other hand, analysts taking a more critical stance on the upgrade highlight two key issues in the public debate:

Firstly, the reduction in Greece’s weighting within MSCI’s global index, which is expected to decline from 0.57% in Emerging Markets to just 0.06% in Developed Markets. A similar decrease is anticipated in its participation in MSCI’s European index, where Greek equities are projected to account for a 0.36% share. In fact, several analysts set the bar even lower, arguing that this development could undermine any potential benefits of the upgrade in terms of investor visibility.

Secondly, the reduction in the number of constituents within the MSCI Greece index (currently eight). Experts estimate that, due to stricter eligibility criteria, the index will likely include only 4 to 5 stocks, with the remainder being excluded from the core index and most likely downgraded to the Small Cap segment. That said, MSCI’s latest simulation (based on February data) still includes seven stocks in the MSCI Greece index, although the final decision will be determined based on 2027 data.

The issue of the upgrade cannot be assessed in isolation from the broader environment. The easing of global geopolitical and energy-related uncertainties, the maintenance of resilient corporate profitability, the continuation of generous dividend distributions, the outperformance of the Greek economy, and the preservation of political stability all constitute necessary conditions for maximizing the potential benefits—or mitigating any adverse effects—arising from Athens’ return to Developed Market status.

Finally, developments regarding the potential inclusion of the Greek market under the Euronext umbrella should also be taken into account.

Προτιμώμενη πηγή στην Google

Για να εμφανίζονται περισσότερα άρθρα της Ναυτεμπορικής στις αναζητήσεις σας εύκολα και γρήγορα, πρέπει να προσθέσετε το site στις προτιμώμενες πηγές σας. Μπορείτε να το κάνετε πηγαίνοντας εδώ.